Bookends 2012 Panel: Taboo

Edel Mulcahy: “‘Of swiche cursed stories I sey fy’: Incest and its consequences in Middle English Exempla”

-Incest as one of the last remaining taboos (Game of Thrones as contemporary example)

– Literary depictions of incest in Medieval period referred to as “cursed stories”

– This paper will examine incest in Middle English Exempla

– Incest as widely discussed  topic in Medieval period (contemporary concern amongst church hierarchy over what constituted incest)

– Medieval writers depicted varied accounts of incest

-Exempla did not ignore incest but used as a cautionary tale

– Used topic as means of exploring God’s capacity for forgiveness

– Women were often the aggressor (women, like their ancestor Eve, have insatiable appetites)

In contrast to Romance narratives in which an elderly father attempts to seduce his daughter

– “The Life of Secundis” – Secundis returns from study like a pilgrim – when he returns home he decides to test what he has learnt about the “lustful nature” of women by seducing his mother

– He lies in bed with her but doesn’t sleep with – her obliviousness to his identity,  in the context of the story, excuse her behaviour

– Removal of the father leads to disorder

– again emphasises forgiving nature of God.

– “The Tale of the Incestuous Daughter” – focuses on importance of divine forgiveness

– Wanton daughter contrasted with devout mother

– daughter sleeps with her father which leads to her eventual murder of the resultant children

– Father seeks repentance – but daughter blames him and ultimately kills him in a brutal manner

– She thus prevents him from undertaking a penitential pilgrimage and thus receiving forgiveness

– Incest is always followed by murder (usually infanticide or patricide)

– Daughter repents before bishop – demonstrating that no sin is too great for God to forgive

– Stories emphasise the importance of confession and repentance

– In Romance tales, it is the father whose desire instigates incest

– it usually propels the daughter from her home

– daughter usually confined to home, but incest narrative gives her an incentive to travel and have adventures usually unavailable to a woman at the time

Kate Kirwan: “Hester Prynne: Sexual Deviant”

Despite the complexity of Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter, the character of Hester Prynne is eternally associated in the lexicon of popular culture with sexual transgression and fallen womanhood

– For example, the troubled character of Audrey Horne in David Lynch’s Twin Peaks uses this name as an alias when she sneaks into a brothel, and the character of Niles and Frasier’s adulteress mother in the sitcom Frasier is named Hester

-However, Hester Prynne is in fact a far more complex character

indeed, while the letter “A” in Hawthorne’s novel initially stands for “adultery”, it eventually comes to have a number or possible (more ambiguous) meanings such as “angel”, “artist” and “able”.

-Kirwan explores some of the different ways in which contemporary literature has reappropriated the figure of Hester Prynne

Hester as America’s first feminist – refuses to surrender her illegitimate daughter to Puritan town elders and supports her small family by working as a seamstress

– Conde’s I Tituba– Hester appears in the jail where the eponymous Tituba is awaiting trial for witchcraft

– Voice she gives to Tituba is not appropriate for the sexually constrained Puritan period

-The character of Hester possesses a fierce, if anachronistic, passion for women’s rights

-Seizes control of her own destiny by committing suicide and bequeathing her feminist spark to Tituba

– John Updike also reappropriates the figure of Hester Prynne

– adultery as “our inherent condition”

– sex and religion reduced to corporeal rather than spiritual entity

– reduces act which ruins Hester to a natural human urge

– Whereas in Hawthorne’s novel she is repentant – Hester is haunted by her act

– Christopher Bigsby’s first Hester novel explores her early life – her relationship with the much older Chillingworth

– Chillingworth in this version is a darker figure

– In Bigsby’s novel Hester does not plan to meet Chillingworth in the new world – she is escaping him (whereas in Hawthorne’s novel she is planning to meet with him and only commences her affair with Dimsdale  when she thinks her husband is dead)

– This Hester also writes a journal which goes against the Puritan idea that private self should be kept hidden.

– In Updike’s novel S.  she is unapologetic about her affairs – she has the capacity to liberate herself and speak her mind

– Updike’s Hester is a more human figure than her literary predecessor

– One of the most complex versions of Hester is in Updike’s Roger’s Version – Hester’s infidelity is exaggerated in Roger’s imagination

-Updike considers Chillingworth to be the most sympathetic character – Hester in Updike’s version is, consequently, cold and distant

– Hester Prynne represents many of the complex traits of femininity

– Modern versions of Hester  are important because they reappropriate her as a figure who has made a mistake and is redeemed rather than simply as the figure of promiscuous, corrupt fallen woman

– These contemporary reimaginings of Hester present her as a complex figure rather than as the clichéd figure of the “fallen woman” she has become in popular culture

– Hester is a product of a culture in which women didn’t have agency or voice – these modern appropriations attempt to give her a voice of her own

Categories: Bookends 2012, Live Blogging, postgraduate conference, University College Cork | Tags: , , , , , , | 1 Comment

Post navigation

One thought on “Bookends 2012 Panel: Taboo

  1. Pingback: Positively Deviant! | Medieval Pilgrimage

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

Photo Narrations

Pictures for the Blind and Sighted.

Ireland - Text and Screen

MA English: Irish Writing and Film

Chris Beausang

Digital Emunction Regarding Novels & Radio & Misc.

Stories, stories everywhere

It's all about the stories

Cian O'Connor

MA in Modernities Research Blog


Spanish Society for Medieval English Language and Literature

Norse in the North

Old Norse and Viking Studies at Durham, York and Leeds

Between the Acts: A Year in UCC's Modernities MA

A personal blog to chart the 2012/13 academic year and any thoughts which occur along the way.

Reflections on Modernities:

A Blog for the Modernities MA at UCC

Finding Charles Clark

1806-1880. Not just another book collector.


Gaelic Ireland and Gaelic Scotland in the later middle ages


Just another site

The Samuel Forde Project

rediscovering an artistic genius

An Academic Life

Life as an English Literature Postgrad


Monstrosity in all its guises

Carrie Griffin

academic & researcher


Forum for Medieval and Renaissance Studies in Ireland - Forum na Meán-Aoise agus an Renaissance in Éirinn

Literary Visuality

Exploring the Visual Qualities of Literature

Medieval Pilgrimage

Pilgrimage during the Middle Ages

%d bloggers like this: